Hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Find the best Shelter Island Heights hotel for your dates, by price or preference

Compare hotel deals across hundreds of providers, all in one place

Look out for Shelter Island Heights hotels with free cancellation or excellent ratings

Trusted Shelter Island Heights hotel providers

See all hotels in Shelter Island Heights

View more hotels
Prices may change – pop in your dates for the best estimate. Note that prices are based on previous traveller searches and partner prices.
Prices may change – pop in your dates for the best estimate. Note that prices are based on previous traveller searches and partner prices.
View more hotels

How to find the best hotel deals in Shelter Island Heights

Want to use the same magic that powers our award-winning flight search to find the best room rates on the internet? Here are a few tips to help you search and save in seconds.

How to find the best hotel deal in Shelter Island Heights

  • Love how easy it is to book flights with us? The same clever search engine is an expert at tracking down deals on Shelter Island Heights hotels too. Follow these tips to find the best rates fast.

  • Save on your Shelter Island Heights hotel and get the room type you actually want by booking early. You'll also have extra time to compare and choose the ideal place.

  • Still, act fast if you spot any last-minute offers. Some places drop their rates shortly before arrival to fill empty rooms. This is more likely to happen on less busy days or in low season, though.

  • Another secret trick to finding cheaper hotels? Flexibility. If your plans aren't written in stone, experiment with your travel dates and discover just how much you can save.

  • Explore the range of accommodation options with free cancellation and book with peace of mind. You can adjust or cancel your stay without penalty if your schedule changes or a better deal comes along.

Where to stay in Shelter Island Heights

Central Shelter Island Heights

  • Choose the city centre and be where it all happens. Take your pick of these stays that keep you near the must-see attractions in central Shelter Island Heights.

  • If you'd like to stay within easy reach of Hay Beach Rd, head straight to Shelter Island House. This Shelter Island Heights hotel is around 5 kilometres from this sight.

When to go to Shelter Island Heights

  • Consider your ideal weather conditions when deciding your trip dates. With maximum highs of 25ºC (77ºF), August offers the warmest conditions.

  • The coolest month here is January. Expect lows of -2ºC (28ºF).

  • If you're hoping for clearer skies, search for Shelter Island Heights hotels during April. With an average of six days of rain, this is the driest month.

  • The wettest time of year is January. Plan your trip then and you'll likely get around eight days of rainfall.

Best hotels in Shelter Island Heights

Best budget hotels

  • Great trips don't need hefty hotel bills. With at least eight budget Shelter Island Heights hotels to choose from, you can spend more on enjoying the city and less on where you lay your head. Expect basic comforts like Wi-Fi, simple breakfasts, and cosy beds at these reasonably priced stays.

  • Shorecrest Bed and Breakfast is a 3-star option that delivers a no-fuss, no-frills stay. Air conditioning and luggage storage are some of its amenities.

  • Alternatively, check the availability at Sag Harbour Inn. Equipped with conveniences such as a safe deposit box and Wi-Fi, this 3-star Shelter Island Heights hotel lets you save without missing out.

  • Air conditioning and Wi-Fi are just a taste of what's on offer at The Rams Head Inn. Another win for your budget goals, this place is rated 3 stars.

Best 4-star hotels in Shelter Island Heights

  • When you want a little extra from your stay, the 4-star hotels in Shelter Island Heights deliver. With around ten choices, they generally feature well-designed rooms, attentive service, and extras like spa treatments and on-site dining. These hotels feel classy without feeling flashy.

  • Find a room at The Chequit and enjoy the elevated comforts that come with this 4-star stay. Take advantage of a golf course and a restaurant while you're here.

  • Another Shelter Island Heights hotel that stands out is Shelter Island House. It features thoughtful amenities such as a restaurant and massage services.

  • Need more to choose from? The Shoals Suites & Slips proves you don't need five stars to feel special. Take advantage of concierge assistance, a fireplace and other extras at this stay.

Best hotels with a pool

  • Add a splash of fun to your getaway with a pool. If you pick a city hotel, expect indoor or rooftop options. Resorts? They usually go big with sprawling outdoor layouts and maybe a swim-up bar or two. There are at least five pool hotels in Shelter Island Heights perfect for your next escape.

  • The Harbour Front Inn offers an outdoor swimming pool, luggage storage and parking. You'll have the right setup for a memorable stay at this Shelter Island Heights hotel.

  • Dive headfirst into comfort at Hotel Moraine. An outdoor swimming pool, a laundry and a private beach are just the beginning of what you can expect here.

Best pet-friendly hotels

  • With around eight pet-friendly Shelter Island Heights hotels, there's no need to leave your best buddy behind. Many have outdoor areas or nearby trails for exercise, and some even offer things like pet-friendly menus or grooming services. A few rules might apply, but most places go out of their way to make your furry friend feel welcome.

  • You bring the treats, The Chequit will take care of the rest. Amenities like parking and a restaurant add to the appeal of this pet-friendly hotel in Shelter Island Heights.

  • Baron's Cove is another place your little buddy will love. This accommodation option comes with Wi-Fi and parking.

Finding cheap hotels in Shelter Island Heights: FAQs

You can always cancel or amend your hotel reservation if you need to, but look out for hotels in Shelter Island Heights with free cancellation or flexible booking options if you want to protect your money. Some hotels allow you to cancel and get your money back if your plans change.