Skyscanner home

Cheap Flights from New York to Toronto Island

Compare New York to Toronto Island flight deals

Find the cheapest month or even day of the year to fly to Toronto Island

Book the best Toronto Island fare with no extra fees

Flight deals from New York to Toronto Island Airport

Looking for a cheap last-minute deal or the best return flight from New York to Toronto Island Airport? If you want to travel next month, return fares start from R 2,603. Find the lowest prices on one-way and return tickets right here.
Toronto.R 1,081 per passenger.Departing Thu, 2 Apr.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Porter Airlines, departs from New York Newark on Thu, 2 Apr, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,081, select.
Toronto.R 1,082 per passenger.Departing Sun, 29 Mar.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Porter Airlines, departs from New York Newark on Sun, 29 Mar, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,082, select.
Toronto.R 1,089 per passenger.Departing Wed, 15 Apr.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Porter Airlines departs from New York Newark on Wed, 15 Apr, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,089, select.
Toronto.R 1,098 per passenger.Departing Mon, 30 Mar.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Porter Airlines departs from New York Newark on Mon, 30 Mar, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,098, select.
Toronto.R 1,523 per passenger.Departing Sat, 20 Jun.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Porter Airlines departs from New York Newark on Sat, 20 Jun, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,523, select.
Toronto.R 1,548 per passenger.Departing Tue, 5 May.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound indirect flight with Porter Airlines, departs from New York Newark on Tue, 5 May, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,548, select.
Toronto.R 1,564 per passenger.Departing Sat, 2 May.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Porter Airlines departs from New York Newark on Sat, 2 May, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,564, select.
Toronto.R 1,866 per passenger.Departing Thu, 2 Jul.One-way flight with Air Canada.Outbound direct flight with Air Canada departs from New York LaGuardia on Thu, 2 Jul, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,866, select.
Toronto.R 1,874 per passenger.Departing Fri, 4 Sep.One-way flight with Air Canada.Outbound direct flight with Air Canada departs from New York LaGuardia on Fri, 4 Sep, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,874, select.
Toronto.R 1,874 per passenger.Departing Fri, 7 Aug.One-way flight with Air Canada.Outbound direct flight with Air Canada departs from New York LaGuardia on Fri, 7 Aug, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,874, select.
Toronto.R 1,874 per passenger.Departing Wed, 7 Oct.One-way flight with Air Canada.Outbound direct flight with Air Canada departs from New York LaGuardia on Wed, 7 Oct, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 1,874, select.
Toronto.R 2,600 per passenger.Departing Sun, 3 Jan.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Porter Airlines departs from New York Newark on Sun, 3 Jan, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 2,600, select.
Toronto.R 2,600 per passenger.Departing Wed, 2 Dec.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Porter Airlines departs from New York Newark on Wed, 2 Dec, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 2,600, select.
Toronto.R 2,600 per passenger.Departing Fri, 13 Nov.One-way flight with Porter Airlines.Outbound direct flight with Porter Airlines departs from New York Newark on Fri, 13 Nov, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 2,600, select.
Toronto.R 3,223 per passenger.Departing Tue, 23 Feb.One-way flight with Air Canada.Outbound direct flight with Air Canada departs from New York LaGuardia on Tue, 23 Feb, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 3,223, select.
Toronto.R 3,250 per passenger.Departing Mon, 1 Mar.One-way flight with Air Canada.Outbound direct flight with Air Canada departs from New York LaGuardia on Mon, 1 Mar, arriving in Toronto Island.Price includes taxes and charges.From R 3,250, select.

Find the cheapest month to fly from New York to Toronto Island

We’re always keeping an eye on fares, so you can find the best one in seconds. It looks like New York to Toronto Island flights are currently cheapest in April.
Mar
from R 1,082
Apr
from R 1,081
May
from R 1,548
Jun
from R 1,523
Jul
from R 1,866
Aug
from R 1,874
Sep
from R 1,874
Oct
from R 1,874
Nov
from R 2,600
Dec
from R 2,600
Jan
from R 2,600
Feb
from R 3,223

Direct flights from New York to Toronto Island

New York to Toronto Island: Alternative routes

Compare routes from New York to Toronto below. You may find an airport to fly into that's cheaper, faster, or easier than Toronto Island.

Toronto Island

3km from central Toronto
ClosestCheapest
from R 1,081
Search flights

Toronto Pearson International

20km from central Toronto
from R 1,089
Search flights

John C. Munro Hamilton

70km from central Toronto
from R 3,321
Search flights

Kitchener / Waterloo

83km from central Toronto
from R 3,821
Search flights

New York to Toronto: Flight information

The things to know before you go.
Cheapest flight foundR 1,081
Cheapest month to flyApril
Average flight time1 hr, 41 mins
Most popular airlineAir Transat
Average flights per week609

Finding cheap flights from New York to Toronto Island: Frequently asked questions

The best price we found for a return flight from New York to Toronto Island is R 2,603. This is an estimate based on information collected from different airlines and travel providers over the last 4 days and is subject to change and availability.
1 hour and 40 minutes is the average flight time from New York to Toronto Island.
Air Transat, Porter Airlines and Porter Airlines Inc fly direct from New York to Toronto Island.
As of March 2026, there are 203 flights per week flying from New York to Toronto Island.
The cheapest month to fly from New York to Toronto Island is usually April.
After crunching the numbers on our flight calendar, we found that it is currently cheapest to fly from New York to Toronto Island Airport on Thursday, 2 April 2026.
Yes – the average flight time is 1 hour and 40 minutes.
We show every price from over 1,200 airlines and travel agents, comparing them all so you don’t have to. If you know you want to fly to Toronto Island but you’re not ready to book, set up a Price Alert. We’ll track prices for you, and let you know when they rise or fall.
We crunched all the numbers in our flight calendar and it looks like the cheapest time to book a flight to Toronto is around 40 days in advance, so don’t leave your flight to the last minute.
The cheapest airline that flies to Toronto Island is Porter Airlines .

Travelling from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ): What you need to know

  • New York has two main airports where you can kick off your trip. Explore your options for booking a flight from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ) heading out from Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR) or New York LaGuardia Airport (LGA).

  • New York and Toronto (where Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport is located) share the UTC-5 timezone. That means you won't have to adjust your watch when you arrive.

  • Leave plenty of time to make your flight from New York to YTZ. As a general rule, arrive at least two hours before international departures and an hour ahead for domestic flights.

  • Going away during a peak month like July? Busy periods (like spring break and Thanksgiving) can add another hour at security. Play things extra safe and arrive up to four hours ahead of international flights and two hours before a domestic departure.

Airports in New York

New York John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK)

  • Stopovers offer the opportunity to discover a new city or just have a break during your travels. When searching for a cheap flight from New York to YTZ, uncheck 'Direct flights only' to browse all potential stops. Montreal-Trudeau International Airport (YUL) is an option when you're setting off from New York John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK).

  • Travelling from central New York to JFK takes around 50 minutes on public transport. If you ride-share, drive or take a taxi, you'll cover the 24 kilometres in 45 minutes or so, depending on traffic conditions.

  • Want a relaxed start to your travels? Stay near New York John F. Kennedy International Airport. Whether you have an early flight from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport or want to avoid feeling rushed, these hotels are just the thing:

  • When it comes to New York John F. Kennedy International Airport's on-time performance, data shows 73% of flights meet their scheduled arrival time.

  • JFK's address is JFK Airport.

Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR)

  • You can book a direct New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ) plane ticket with departures from Newark Liberty International Airport (EWR). See if flying from EWR works better for your plans.

  • Get on your direct flight from New York to YTZ with Porter Airlines. This is one of the leading carriers that operates this route out of EWR.

  • On the EWR to YTZ route, Porter Airlines (Canada) Ltd is the go-to airline for most travellers.

  • Among the carriers operating flights between Newark Liberty International Airport and Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport, Porter Airlines (Canada) Ltd has the most consistent on-time performance.

  • You can get to EWR from central New York in approximately 35 minutes by car (depending on traffic). The journey on public transport takes roughly 1 hour to cover the 24 kilometres or so.

  • Want to enjoy an extra night away before your New York to YTZ flight? Kick back in a hotel near Newark Liberty International Airport before your trip officially starts. These stays are calling your name:

  • When it comes to flights staying on schedule, Newark Liberty International Airport has an on-time arrival performance of 71%.

  • The street address for EWR is Building 1, Conrad Road.

New York LaGuardia Airport (LGA)

  • Make it to your destination faster from New York LaGuardia Airport (LGA). Direct flights from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport can be booked from here.

  • Get set for takeoff with Air Canada. It offers direct New York to YTZ plane tickets from LGA.

  • The preferred airline for passengers flying between LGA and YTZ is Air Canada.

  • LGA is around 13 kilometres from central New York. The drive from the city centre to the airport takes about 30 minutes. If you're planning to use public transport, expect a journey time of around 55 minutes.

  • Stay in bed a little longer and still make your New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport flight with time to spare. These hotels near New York LaGuardia Airport make departure day effortless if you're jetting off early:

  • Flights that take off from LGA touch down at their destination on schedule 69% of the time.

  • You'll find New York LaGuardia Airport at Hangar 7 Centre.

About Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ)

  • If you have a late flight from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport, nothing tops the convenience of staying near the terminal. Collect your bags from the carousel and then be showered and sleeping soon after at one of these options near YTZ:

  • Lock in the best rate by booking your vehicle around one week ahead of your New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport flight.

Getting from Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ) to central Toronto

  • From Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport, central Toronto is around 3 kilometres away. It takes about 10 minutes to reach the city centre by car.

  • If you're travelling by public transport, expect a journey time of around 20 minutes.

How to find the cheapest flights from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ)

  • The cheapest price we've found for a one-way ticket from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport is R 1,081. For a return flight on this route, the best price is R 2,603. Depending on when you want to go and the availability, these fares could change.

  • To find cheap flights from New York to YTZ, book in advance. Airlines usually offer the most competitive fares when flights are first released.

  • The 'Whole month' tool will show you the cheapest New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport tickets across each month. It's a good way to find a bargain if your trip dates aren't set in stone.

  • There's no need to check back in every day to find out if fares have dropped when you create a Price Alert. We'll let you know as soon as there's a better deal on plane tickets from New York to YTZ.

  • Uncover a great deal on a flight from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport with the help of the filters. Pick your ideal departure and arrival times, number of stops and airlines. You can also sort your results by 'Fastest,' 'Best' or 'Cheapest.'

The best time to fly from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ)

  • November is the busiest month for flights from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport (YTZ). Plan your visit to Toronto in January for a more laid-back experience.

  • Book a New York to YTZ plane ticket departing in July if you want to visit the city during its warmest month. You can expect temperatures in Toronto to range from 15ºC (59ºF) to 28ºC (82ºF).

  • February has temperatures of between -15ºC (5ºF) and 3ºC (37ºF). Look for cheap tickets from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport around that time if you like travelling in cooler conditions.

More about Toronto

  • When it comes to searching for somewhere to lay your head, you'll find the best places to stay in Toronto right here. Explore these options once you've locked in your flight from New York to Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport:

  • All great holidays should include a little sightseeing. CN Tower, The Top CN Tower and Royal Ontario Museum are attractions you won't want to skip in Toronto.

Explore more of Canada

  • You've visited Toronto, now it's time to discover other parts of Canada. Journey about 161 kilometres southwest to London to check off its leading sights. From Forks of the Thames River to Fanshawe Pioneer Village and Storybook Gardens, you'll have a full itinerary ahead.

  • Around 241 kilometres east of Toronto, Kingston is another essential stop in Canada. No visit is complete without checking out Fort Henry, Rideau Canal - Jones Falls Defensible Lockmasters House and Kingston Penitentiary.

Plan the rest of your trip from New York to Toronto

Prices shown on this page are estimated lowest prices only. Found in the last 45 days.